In Theaters: Thursday 1st July 2004
Box Office USA: $0.6M
Distributed by: TLA Releasing
Production compaines: TLA Releasing
Contactmusic.com: 2.5 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 43%
Fresh: 20 Rotten: 26
IMDB: 7.3 / 10
Director: C. Jay Cox
Screenwriter: C. Jay Cox
Starring: Steve Sandvoss as Elder Aaron Davis, Wes Ramsey as Christian Markelli, Rebekah Johnson as Julie Taylor (as Rebekah Jordan), Amber Benson as Traci Levine, Khary Payton as Andrew, Jacqueline Bisset as Lila Montagne, Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Elder Paul Ryder, Rob McElhenney as Elder Harmon, Dave Power as Elder Gilford, Erik Palladino as Keith Griffin
Call it fate (or call it the grinding gears of C. Jay Cox's screenplay) that plops a quartet of young Mormon missionaries including the tormented Aaron (Steve Sandvoss) into the LA apartment complex where shallow West Hollywood superstud and overall gay Adonis Christian (Wesley A. Ramsey) just happens to live across the way. Christian, his roommate Julie (Rebekah Johnson), and the other waiters at the restaurant where they work are highly amused by these uptight guys in white shirts and ties who seem to have landed from another planet. A bet is quickly made (grind, grind goes the screenplay): If Christian can bed a Mormon and snag his "sacred underwear," he'll win $50. It shouldn't be tough for a sexually magnetic guy who seems to have left a trail of satisfied one-night-stands from Santa Monica to San Bernardino.
Slipping into a tight tank top and short shorts, Christian immediately sets his sights on Aaron, the newest and youngest of the group, and begins a flirtation in the laundry room and during a game of shirts and skins hoops. Luckily, Aaron seems more than ready to experiment. No sooner has Christian stripped down to his black jock strap so Aaron can help him patch up a cut on his leg than Aaron lays his head down on Christian's tanned and hairless chest.
The bet doesn't end there, however. The first kiss between Christian and Aaron happens later and is witnessed by Aaron's Mormon friends, and that means trouble. Aaron is quickly whisked away and sent back to his family in Idaho, and Christian is left alone to wonder about some new feelings. Is this what guilt feels like? Is this emptiness? Is this love? Full of remorse, Christian even chases Aaron to the Salt Lake City airport, but after a night of hotel sex ("I'm going to hell anyway," says Aaron. "I may as well take the scenic route."), Aaron disappears, and Christian feels worse.
Feeling a need to atone for his sin, Christian begins delivering meals to homebound AIDS victims. In one of the film's few truly honest moments, AIDS sufferer Keith (Erik Palladino) asks Christian what a "pretty boy" like him is doing delivering meals. You must be punishing yourself for something, Keith suggests, and Christian, who's searching his soul for the first time in his life, can't disagree.
In a story such as this, lovers torn asunder will have to reconnect, but not for a while. While Aaron becomes persona non grata, even to his own mother (Mary Kay Place), Christian tries to hunt him down. Meanwhile, in a highly improbable and unrelated event, roommate Julie becomes an overnight singing sensation complete with her own hot music video. Coincidences begin to pile up thick and fast, and screenwriter Cox is so aware of them that he even has the maternal restaurant owner Lila (Jacqueline Bisset, gorgeous as always) opine that "I don't believe in coincidences... I believe in miracles." It's a nice sentiment but a huge screenwriting copout.
And how strange and funny that the characters discuss angels and Cox (who was raised in a Mormon family, by the way) even puts a woman wearing a set of angel wings on a bus stop bench. You'd think the last thing he'd want to do is remind the audience of the power and sweep of Angels in America.
The DVD adds deleted scenes, music videos, commentary from Cox, Ramsey, and Sandovoss, and a short film from Cox.