In Theaters: Thursday 12th May 2005
Box Office USA: $0.6M
Distributed by: IFC Films
Contactmusic.com: 4 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 78%
Fresh: 79 Rotten: 22
IMDB: 7.1 / 10
Director: Guy Maddin
Starring: Isabella Rossellini as Lady Helen Port-Huntley, Mark McKinney as Chester Kent, Maria de Medeiros as Narcissa, David Fox as Fyodor Kent, Ross McMillan as Roderick Kent / Gravillo the Great, Louis Negin as Blind Seer, Darcy Fehr as Teddy
All of which seems to further 2003 as the year of the outlandish fantasy. As Sylvain Chomet's singular vision brought us a work derived purely from an irrepressibly inventive mind with The Triplets of Belleville, here Canadian director Guy Maddin (Dracula: Pages from a Virgin's Diary, Fleshpots of Antiquity) works from a co-authored original screenplay with Kazuo Ishiguro (The Remains of the Day) in a manner that combines the storytelling and musical vitality of Topsy-Turvy with the visual imagery out of the German expressionism of F.W. Murnau (Nosferatu, The Phantom) but with its own richness of character. I call it "high concept 8mm."
It's Winnipeg, Canada, during the Great Depression when people would do just about anything for a loaf of bread. But, even amidst this general destitution and unemployment, there were still The Rich. One of these, beer magnate Lady Port-Huntly (Isabella Rossellini) -- slightly crazed, somewhat demented (for good reason) -- this "Queen of the Brew" puts on a contest to determine the "saddest music in the world."
Her purse of $25,000 -- a literal fortune for the times -- brings musicians from far and wide and, most significantly, the impresario love of her life since before she lost her legs in an accident, Chester Kent (Mark McKinney). While his close companion is, for the moment, Narcissa (the ravishing, unrestrainable Maria de Medeiros from Pulp Fiction), he's not above using Port-Huntley's torch for him as a means to acquire a contest win.
His father Fyodor (David Fox), a doctor, responsible for the surgical screw-up that cost the Baroness her legs, has abandoned his medical career and is making up for his disgrace by fashioning a pair of prosthetic legs made from beer-filled glass. She revels in the newfound ability to walk even while she judges the weird but musically accomplished contest.
The competition brings out Chester's brother, Roderick (Ross McMillan), traveling as a Serbian entrant with the stage name of Gavrilo the Great, Europe's Greatest Cello, which he uses to plumb the deepest chords of grief. His inspiration for the emotional bottoming is brother Kent's compliant and passionate lover, Narcissa, whom Roderick claims as his long lost wife.
McKinney is slick as the ever-opportunistic impresario, terrible son, and worse brother, bringing to mind a young Orson Welles in control of the world. Rossellini is in her métier here to a greater extent than I've ever seen her, relishing her vampy, dismembered creation, ignoring the idea of being handicapped. She's on top of this material and runs with it (pun intended) for all the legless momentum the wacky vision affords. And, for that matter, so do all involved.
De Medeiros, when given the script, referred to it as "precarious." That it is. This is material for the fiscally adventurous, appealing to those with a taste for a work by a moviemaking tightrope walker. It might even bring in those who love an interesting, slightly giddy musical, and it should.
IFC Films should be lauded for having the guts and sense of adventure to make this insanely audacious satire. But they deserve more than a pat on the back. Anyone who respects originality ardently may hope it flushes out a wide audience and some payback for sheer hallucinatory daring.
Two making-of featurettes and two short films from director Guy Maddin can be found on the film's DVD.
The saddest makeup in all the world.