American-raised actor Lawrence (Del Toro) returns to his family manor on an English moor, where his wild-haired father Sir John (Hopkins) lives with his Sikh servant (Malik). Lawrence discovers that his brother has just been killed in the woods by a vicious creature, which later wounds him as well, turning him into a werewolf. And on the first full moon, he finds himself on the hunt as well as chased by a Scotland Yard detective (Weaving). But maybe a gypsy woman (Chaplin) and his brother's ex-fiancee (Blunt) hold the key to his salvation.
There's definitely the sense that this film has been tampered with along the way, as reshoots are clearly visible here and there, and the choppy story editing leaves no sign that gifted writers like Walker and Self were involved.
The dialog is merely daft cliches strung together almost completely separate from the plot, which is a by-the-books schlocker. And the hyped-up gothic production design nearly overwhelms us with fog, shadows and dust-infused shafts of strategically placed light.
In other words, there's barely a moment of subtlety anywhere, although Blunt and Del Toro try to give their characters a hint of thoughtfulness when they can. Hopkins has a ball with his mad-eyed character, who has a strong whiff of Hannibal Lecter about him. Meanwhile, Weaving is amusing as the arrogant, eyebrow-arching detective, and Sher is hilarious as a slithery psychiatist who's clearly doomed to die a horrible death from the moment we meet him.
Fortunately, there's a sense that the filmmakers were actually going for broke with the silliness, as witnessed in the classic-style make-up design and some gleefully preposterous action scenes. The problem is that they never seem sure what they're trying to achieve: it's never remotely scary, despite constant red herrings and loud soundtrack jolts, and it's never overtly comical, even though it would be difficult to make a spoof that was any goofier than this.
Run time: 103 mins
In Theaters: Friday 12th February 2010
Box Office USA: $61.9M
Distributed by: Universal Pictures
Production compaines: Stuber Productions, Universal Pictures, Relativity Media
Contactmusic.com: 2.5 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 34%
Fresh: 72 Rotten: 138
IMDB: 5.8 / 10
Director: Joe Johnston
Starring: Benicio del Toro as Lawrence Talbot, Anthony Hopkins as Sir John Talbot, Emily Blunt as Gwen Conliffe, Hugo Weaving as Inspector Francis Abberline, Cristina Contes as Solana Talbot, David Sterne as Kirk, Elizabeth Croft as Ophelia, Simon Merrells as Ben Talbot, Art Malik as Singh, Asa Butterfield as Young Ben, Geraldine Chaplin as Maleva