Silver City Movie Review

Subscribe to Chris Cooper alerts
What are they using on the moviemaking plantation this election year to have produced such a bumper crop of Democrat-leaning political films? The fertile harvest may have something to do with outright fear of a Bush win in November. Or, determination to clarify the issues for swing voters still formulating their judgments.

Now, after Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11, Robert Greenwald's Uncovered: The War on Iraq, France's The World According to Bush, the upcoming Bush's Brain, and many more, filmmaker John Sayles adds his satiric shovelful with Silver City, a (fictional) feature film which explores the ramifications of a political system that lends itself to corrupt and unseemly influences.

The film is aesthetically all over the place: sleep-inducing expository scenes (most of those with Tim Roth, for some reason), classy flashes of performance and character (most of those with Maria Bello and one with fetching Thora Birch), platitudes and caricature (most of those with Richard Dreyfuss and Billy Zane), mixed in with missed opportunities for stylish drama because of pedestrian staging. But Chris Cooper's performance as the inept candidate -- styled on George W. Bush, down to his mental tendency toward verbal destruction -- is the reason the film has to be seen.

Which may be a difficult sell. The critics aren't raving and this may turn out to be a low altitude attainment on the Sayles monument of film, but it won't be because of the weaknesses enumerated above. Its failure on pure moviemaking criteria has more to do with the actor chosen for the lead character: Taking us through the players and malefactors in the exposé of a politically corrupt land grab and an overconfident campaign that begins with the discovery of a dead body is ex-reporter Danny O'Brien (Danny Huston), now employed as an investigator for a political P.I. firm led by hard-as-putty Grace Seymour (Mary Kay Place).

Huston is nice and affable, and candidate Pilager's estranged daughter Maddy (Daryl Hannah) thinks he's cute, and this is backed up by the assertion that he's the ex of gorgeous reporter Nora Allardyce (Bello). But leading man material? Where's the dynamism of Jude Law, Matt Damon, or Will Smith? Has Sayles abandoned all hope of putting together a commercial success? Did no one advise him that Huston, who played "hotel manager" in Hotel and "herdsman" in The Bacchae (don't ask me!) was entrusted with too much?

Everyone involved gives it their all, and this includes a stellar ensemble cast with the likes of Miguel Ferrer, Kris Kristofferson, Michael Murphy, the salty James Gammon, and an energetic moment with Ralph Waite. Sayles fans will not want to miss his latest quirky venture but Democrats most of all will not want to miss this contribution to the campaign.

The DVD adds a making-of featurette plus a commentary from Sayles and producer Maggie Renzi.

Silver City? I thought we were going to Gold City!

Subscribe to Chris Cooper alerts


Silver City Rating

" Weak "

Rating: R, 2004


More Chris Cooper

Pharrell Takes His Hat To 'The Amazing Spider-Man 2' NY Premiere - Part 3

'Happy' singer Pharrell Williams and his famously large hat were spotted amongst the crowd at the New York premiere for 'The Amazing Spider-Man 2' alongside...

The Amazing Spider-man 2 Movie Review

As with the too-early franchise reboot in 2012, this sequel struggles to balance the demands of a teen romance with a superhero blockbuster. The interpersonal...

The Amazing Spiderman 2 - Clips Trailer

Peter Parker is facing a period of deep confusion in every aspect of his life. No longer is everything black and white, nor is it...

August: Osage County Movie Review

Tracy Letts adapts his own prize-winning play into a blistering depiction of one of cinema's most dysfunctional families ever. It's still rather theatrical, throwing a...


August: Osage County And Meryl Streep Win Big At Capri, Hollywood Film Festival

After early predictions pegged the Meryl Streep and Julia Roberts starrer August: Osage County as a frontrunner for awards season 2014, the film has now...

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Trailer

Peter Parker has always had difficulty trying to prioritise his life. There's the personal side of it; the ordinary teenage angst, trying to hold down...

August: Osage County Trailer

The Weston family know they are probably one of the most dysfunctional families around, but they do understand that sometimes it's best to stick together....

Paul Giamatti Continues American Invasion Of Downton Abbey With Season Four Appearance

Paul Giamatti will become the next American actor to appear in the hugely successful British period drama Downton Abbey, with the American Splendour actor set...