The Grudge 2 Movie Review

Subscribe Amber Tamblyn
Low cost and high quality: Japan is king when it comes to assembly line production ethos and Grudge 2 director Takashi Shimizu takes that manufacturing approach in constructing this latest edition in the Grudge series. Block by block, shock by shock, he builds a movie that runs fine and looks slick. It's a solid product in terms of celluloid, but there is no soul, no artistry, in the merchandise. What went wrong? Enthusiasm. Shimizu seems to take pride only in the technical proficiency of his work. Actors be damned. Plot be damned. While there's nothing wrong with a really well-made but vacuous art-horror film (Dario Argento's entire canon fits this mold), there is no art in the Grudge 2, just cleverly staged shock shots stapled on to the other like the reels of skin in Sion Soto's Suicide Club (had to plug some good J-horror here somewhere.)

Perhaps this calculating demeanor is because Shimizu's essentially made the same film six times now. The first Ju-on in 2000. The second in 2000 as well. Then he did both of them again in 2003. Then the American remake in 2004. That makes Grudge 2 the sixth version of the same film made in only six years. (In between he made the similar Marebito and Rinne.) It's not surprising that the film feels mechanized, paint by numbers. Shimizu has either got it down so pat that he can operate on autopilot or he's just bored senseless.

The plot -- as it is -- consists of random opportunities for the titular grudgely ghoulies (a family of pale ghosts) to plague the lives of common day schoolgirls (and one reporter) and scare the crap out of them while pulling them through mirrors or phone booths. There's really no reason to see the first film in the series -- you get the back story three of four times in this film -- but it goes a little something like this: A long time ago (I'm guessing it's the mid-'80s) a man killed his wife, child, and obnoxious black cat. Then he hung himself.

This ghastly crime was so atrocious it reverberates down through history and anyone entering the house the family was killed in will be haunted by the family unto death (or disappearance). Keeping with every J-horror cliché (Shimizu invented most of them) the mother ghost (with long black hair hanging in front of her eyes, natch) moves like she's being stop motion animated by teens looking to put something up on YouTube, the little boy ghost -- all blue 'cause he was drowned -- pops out from under desks and howls like a cat with laryngitis, and the dad rarely makes an appearance but when he does it's usually to crack some necks. Simple enough. And those visitations were creepy enough to fill the short running time of the first movie, but The Grudge 2 has no new game. We're treated to almost every ghosting and gruesome dispatch from the first film, just in a different order.

To be fair, Grudge 2 does have one intersteing and mildly original plot device. As things play out predictably in Japan, something rotten is happening in Chicago. A family moves into a new apartment to find the neighboring children seem to be possessed by something really eerie. This sideline plot (it connects up at the end of the film with the Japan hauntings) is more effective and honestly should have been the main focus of the picture (I know, I know, that will be Grudge 3.)

Shimizu knows how to make an effective shock sequence. He's good at tension. Good at lighting scary set pieces. But despite this technical proficiency there isn't an original bone in Grudge 2's over-long 95 minutes. Hell, if I'd made the same film six times I'd be pretty damn good at it too. That or really, really bored.

What's black and white and red all over?

Cast & Crew

Director : Takaski Shimizu

Producer : , Roy Lee, Joe Drake

Subscribe Amber Tamblyn


The Grudge 2 Rating

" Grim "

Rating: PG-13, 2006


More Amber Tamblyn

Quentin Tarantino's The Hateful Eight: Who's Playing Who?

Quentin Tarantino recently hosted a live read through of the screenplay for his latest film The Hateful Eight, which by many accounts heralds in a...

Amber Tamblyn Ascends To 'Two And A Half Men' Series Regular

Actress Amber Tamblyn has been announced to have been promoted to series regular on sitcom Two and a Half Men. Tamblyn appeared in five episodes...

A Week In News: Willis Quits Expendables 3, Hoffman Beats Cancer and Beyonce Chops Hair Off

$1 Million A Day? Bruce Willis is officially out of The Expendables 3, having been replaced by Harrison Ford. The thing is, there appears to...

And 'Two and a Half Men's' Lesbian Daughter Is...Amber Tamblyn.

Amber Tamblyn has landed the high profile role of Jenny, the lesbian daughter of the late Charlie Harper (Charlie Sheen) on Two and a Half...


Best Wedding Ever? Aaron Paul and Lauren Parsekian Hire John Mayer, David Blaine

Breaking Bad star Aaron Paul has married his long-time girlfriend Lauren Parsekian at a ceremony at Cottage Pavilion at Calamigos Ranch in Malibu on Sunday...

Top 10 Celebrity Weddings of 2012: From Nutty Nuptials To Classy Ceremonies

There must have been something in the air this year because we literally had too many celebrity weddings to choose from for this list (sorry...

Call Me Professor Questlove… The Roots’ Drummer To Teach At NYU

We all know Questlove, right? The drummer for The Roots, a high profile musician in his own right and Amber Tamblyn’s amateur wedding photographer? Well,...

Amber Tamblyn's Dress Steals The Day At Her Wedding To David Cross

Amber Tamblyn's dress was the real star of the show as the American actress and poet tied the knot with comedian and actor David Cross...