The Man from Elysian Fields Movie Review

James Coburn is just great in The Man from Elysian Fields, one of his final performances before recently succumbing to a heart attack. As a dying, once-great novelist, the veteran actor displays a combination of fire and vulnerability that makes him a riveting presence.

Unfortunately, such generous adjectives can't be used for Elysian, which has a promising premise but does little of interest with it. Andy Garcia plays Byron Triller, a struggling novelist who has mounds of trouble supporting his young family. Out of luck and out of nowhere, Byron meets a mysterious, upscale pimp, Luther (Mick Jagger), who thinks Byron would be an ideal addition to his escort service.

Byron is initially reluctant, but he's soon regularly dating the beautiful wife (Olivia Williams) of great novelist Tobias Alcott (Coburn). Alcott understands that he can't satisfy his wife anymore and accepts Byron. Soon after, he learns of Byron's other profession and asks Byron to evaluate his manuscript. That opportunity begins a chain of events that affects Byron's personal and professional life, especially his relationship with his supportive and somewhat oblivious wife (Julianna Marguiles).

The acting in Elysian is solid, especially from Coburn as well as Jagger -- who seems to have been born for this role. Coburn and Garcia also have some great scenes together, showing the passion writers have for their work. But Phillip Jayson Lasker's script lets everybody down. Byron's decision to alter his lifestyle is handled with about as much urgency as if he was buying a new pair of loafers. You're never fully convinced that he's risking anything. The filmmakers also ruin Luther by briefly chronicling his love affair with a client (Anjelica Huston in a pointless role). Their two scenes go a long way in destroying the influence Luther has on Byron, as well as puncturing his persona as a mysterious lothario. Lasker probably wanted to prove a point about the perils of fidelity but it deflates any on-screen sexiness (which is oddly lacking to begin with).

Enjoying Elysian takes a pretty big leap of faith, but the sense of convenience eventually becomes smothering. The ending feels overwhelmingly phony, considering the string of struggles that continue to befall Byron. Hasn't the guy suffered enough already? A movie at its best is a form of virtual reality; it's a representation of another world. At about the 80-minute point in Elysian, we see how the strings are pulled. Suddenly, hackneyed events take place that seem done solely to drum up emotions and to get the best possible ending. Marguiles's character suddenly gets a backbone, Williams's character does an about face that comes straight from a soap opera and Byron gets one step closer to living in a dumpster. And there's more after that.

I would have enjoyed Elysian more if the filmmakers had tried to ease off the dramatic fireworks and just let the characters and their dilemmas naturally progress. By the end, we don't feel as if we know the people or what they've endured. All we know for sure is that Coburn will be missed.

Pull harder.


Johney Heart's picture

Johney Heart

Your review was great although I didn't agree with your opinion of the film making. I found the story-telling to be powerful in that it projected the blanket of sadness that covered all the characters in the story. Luther's affair with his client was not so pointless in that it emphasized the loneliness of the ageing escort who now thought that he had found love (remember, he had decided to retire from the business). There was a powerful message in her response to his proposal: she had only ever viewed him as a prostitute and had no intention of leaving her husband for him. It was a similar message that Byron gets from Tobias’s wife after Tobias dies. Byron’s supporting character (the other male escort working in Luther’s business) delivers a great line when he is asked by Byron’s wife why would a man be an escort; he replies “when a man feels impotent, all he has left is f**king”. Perhaps the message of this film has more to do with the folly of how a male sees himself in the eyes of the woman or women he is bedding versus the reality of how they might actually see him: we are not necessarily adored just because we are fun and a good lay!

8 years 1 month ago
View Comments

The Man from Elysian Fields Rating

" Weak "

Rating: R, 2001


More Andy Garcia

Kill The Messenger Trailer

Kill the Messenger follows the real life story of Journalist Gary Webb (Jeremy Renner), as he stumbles upon the story of a lifetime. When Webb...

"What's A D-k Turd?" Celebs Read Mean Tweets Is Back With Episode 7!

Get ready to rub your hands together with glee and cackle at the daily abuse celebrities have to field via Twitter. For Jimmy Kimmel's famous...

Let's Be Cops Trailer

A pair of best pals are at the point where they are contemplating why nothing in their lives seems to have turned out right so...

'Rio 2': Critics Squawk Their First Verdicts On The Colourful Kids' Comedy [Trailer]

Don't you know about the bird? Well, Spix's Macaw to be precise and a new kids' movie that's bound to get you feeling in the...


Rio 2 Movie Review

After the snappy, clever 2011 original, this sequel feels rather lazy by comparison: it's still visually colourful and sometimes witty, but the overcrowded story is...

Review Round-Up : 'At Middleton' Is Simple And Sweet With Some Star Performances

Andy Garcia and Vera Farmiga star in AdamRodgers' romantic comedyAt Middleton, as two seemingly opposite people who bond while accompanying their children on a university...

Rio 2 Trailer

Blu and Jewel believe that they are two of a kind as the only full grown blue macaws in existence as they make their home...

Rob The Mob Trailer

Tommy and Rosie are a young couple living in New York who are madly in love with one another - mad enough that they begin...