The Princess Diaries Movie Review

Subscribe Anne Hathaway
Anne Hathaway is a gorgeous, young woman with a gentle screen charisma. It's hard to believe she will turn 19 this fall; she looks and presents herself like a woman who knows all the answers.

This is someone who should not be the lead role in a movie about puberty blues, but here she is. In Garry Marshall's latest outing, The Princess Diaries, Hathaway plays a smart, gawky 10th grader who learns she is the heir to the throne of a small European country.

The news is broken to Hathaway by her long-lost grandmother (Julie Andrews), queen of fictional Genovia, while she tends to business at the country's embassy in San Francisco. Genovia is in desperate need of a ruler and needs Hathaway to take over after her father's death. Despite her doubts, California klutz Hathaway agrees to take "princess lessons" from Andrews and trusted chauffer Hector Elizondo before deciding whether to rule a country or take the SATs.

This is all very familiar territory for Marshall, who directed Pretty Woman over a decade ago. However, Pretty Woman worked because of a brilliantly brash performance by a pre-superstar Julia Roberts and the movie's take as an adult fairly tale. With The Princess Diaries, there isn't anything distinctive to make it particularly memorable.

Among the flaws in Gina Wendkos' script, based on Meg Cabot's novel, is the constant reliance on Hathaway's clumsiness. She breaks things, has trouble putting on panty hose, falls down a lot. I'd love to see the day when a comedy doesn't have to feature a beautiful woman flailing around like she has an inner ear problem. Words can be just as funny coming out of a woman's mouth as they can a man's. Watch Madeline Kahn in Young Frankenstein for proof.

The script also doesn't have the wink-wink humor (like Shrek) that makes a family film appealing to adults. While the goofiness and pretty cast (teen siren Mandy Moore has a sizable role as Hathaway's nemesis) will certainly satisfy kids, there's really not a lot for grown-ups to enjoy. Andrews and Elizondo (in Pretty Woman mode) give spirited performances, but they don't get a lot to do. However, a dance scene between the two is the movie's sweetest moment and hints at what could have been.

This is Hathaway's movie, which is both a good and a bad thing. She's positively stunning and shows talent despite the clunky plot. However, I have a major problem with her character. Even in frizzy hair and Elvis Costello glasses, she would be popular in just about any high school in America. You can only imagine what Hathaway looks like in princess mode.

Still, the leggy, elegant Hathaway is the lead in a movie that takes a somewhat serious look at the awkwardness of growing up and the value of a person's character. I saw the movie with an audience during a Friday matinee, consisting mostly of kids who probably are or soon will be going through the same problems. Certainly, The Princess Diaries isn't the only culprit of questionable adolescent casting: Varsity Blues and She's All That immediately come to mind as well. In The Princess Diaries, Hathaway's presence also deflates her character's regal metamorphosis. What exactly was there to transform in the first place?

The Princess Diaries on DVD is largely what you'd expect, though Garry Marshall's introductions of his deleted scenes (as well as his commentary track) are insane and worth checking out. Is he on something? Does he think he's the king of Genovia? Don't laugh... yet. The new two-disc Special Edition cut adds more outtakes and bloopers, more featurettes, and more Hathaway goodness, all presented in THX-certified super-sound.

Some country you got there.

Subscribe Anne Hathaway


The Princess Diaries Rating

" Weak "

Rating: G, 2001


More Anne Hathaway

A Week In Movies: Interstellar Lands In Cinemas, Tarantino Hosts The Hateful Eight, And Dumb & Dumber To Premieres In L.A., Plus New Trailers For Furious 7, Ex Machina And Minions

After earlier permieres in L.A. And London, Interstellar held a week-of-release premiere on Monday in New York, attended by Christopher Nolan and his wife producer...

Interstellar Is A New Genre For Nolan

Over the past 15 years, Christopher Nolan has proven himself as a master of intelligent filmmaking, generally sticking to the psychological thriller genre while mixing...

Interstellar Movie Review

Brainy blockbuster maestro Christopher Nolan heads into deep space with this epic adventure, which is packed with thoughtful ideas and big emotions even if the...

Matthew McConaughey Leads Arrivals At 'Interstellar' NY Premiere - Part 1

'Interstellar''s lead star Matthew McConaughey was seen arriving at the movie's premiere at AMC Loews Lincoln Square theater in New York alongside his wife Camila...


Interstellar - Nolan's "Flawless Masterpiece"

The New York premiere of Christopher Nolan’s eagerly-awaited survivalist space epic, Interstellar, attracted a wealth of fabulously dressed celebrities on Monday night including its main...

Matthew McConaughey: "Interstellar is the Wildest Ride I've Seen on Film"

Matthew McConaughey has called Christopher Nolan's new sci-fi epic Interstellar "wilder than any other ride" seen on screen. Anticipation for the space-exploration blockbuster has been...

Anne Hathaway Recalls Embarrassing Moment At Matthew McConaughey's House Party

Anne Hathaway wanted to get to know her 'Interstellar' co-star Matthew McConaughey better, so when his wife Camila Alves asked her to attend a surprise...

McConaughey's 'Insterstellar' To Screen at 3am as Demand Increases

We're still three weeks away from the release of Christopher Nolan's shadowy movie Interstellar, but speculation is already hotting up regarding the potential of this...