Under the Roofs of Paris Review
By Christopher Null
Under the Roofs is a sweet and simple little film, a standard love triangle among a Romanian immigrant, a local mobster, and a street artist. The worth of Under the Roofs comes from its pioneering use of sound -- which Clair reportedly disliked anyway -- in which Clair resorts to clever conceits to add nuance to some equally interesting camerawork.
Case in point: During an otherwise standard fight scene, the William Tell Overture plays as if it's part of the soundtrack. Only when a record starts skipping and the proprietor comes to turn off the Victrola do we realize it was part of the scene. The repeating music is such a nuisance it actually stops the fight.
Clair's production design is so clever it makes his story's weaknesses all the more visible. Sure, there's a thinly-veiled exaltation of the urban, lower classes, but there's little to be gleaned from a plot that had already become tired 70 years ago.
Still, it's an important piece of cinema history, improved by a crystal transfer to digital and enhanced by an outtake (not restored) of the original opening and Clair's Paris qui dort, a 1924 feature that Clair eventually pared down into a 30 minute short.
Aka Sous les toits de Paris.
Facts and Figures
Year: 1930
Run time: 96 mins
In Theaters: Thursday 2nd January 1930
Distributed by: Criterion Collection
Reviews
Contactmusic.com: 3 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 89%
Fresh: 17 Rotten: 2
IMDB: 7.4 / 10
Cast & Crew
Director: René Clair
Producer: René Clair
Screenwriter: René Clair
Starring: Albert Préjean as Albert, a young street singer, Pola Illéry as Pola, a Roumanian girl, Edmond T. Gréville as Louis, Albert's friend, Bill Bocket as Bill, The Big Boss, Gaston Modot as Fred, a purse thief