Movie Reviews (2) The Amazing Spider-man

Subscribe to Spider Man alerts

The overwhelming concensus among film critics is that The Amazing SPIDER-MAN is perfectly adequate summertime fare and a clear improvement over Spider-Man 3 , while not measuring up to the first two Spider-Man movies. Several critics credit the performance of British actor Andrew Garfield in the title role for lifting it above the usual razzle-dazzle of mostly computer-generated superhero movies. Michael Phillips in the Chicago Tribune remarks that Garfield represents a significant change from predecessor Tobey Maguire. "He's a rebel with a cause and ultralight ultra-thin metal cable shooting out of his wrists. And he's very good." Peter Howell in the Toronto Star is one of a number of critics who praise the film but maintain that it is a far cry from the original two. Nevertheless, he writes, "Andrew Garfield makes a dandy Peter and an even better Spidey, being far closer to the smartass Marvel Comics original than Tobey Maguire's rather wan depiction." In the San Francisco Chronicle , Mick LaSalle comments, "Garfield is not nearly as charming or as idiosyncratic as Tobey Maguire. But Maguire's reflective quality often rendered him passive. Garfield, a good actor, has a prickly, ruffled undertone that makes him, by nature, more active, more angry and more suited to prowling the streets at night. It's easier to believe in his anger." And Ann Hornaday in the Washington Post also finds Garfield's portray impressive. "With his soulful brown eyes and mop of untamed hair, Garfield is winningly believable as a shy, nerdy outcast -- and just as credible as the scrambling, preternaturally limber superhero who Saves The Day," she writes. But a handful of critics refuse to go along. Lou Lumenick of the New York Post is one of them, remarking that Garvield could have made a fine Spidey "if he had been given a better script with something like the wit, charm and energy of the first two Spider-Man' films. Instead, he's saddled with a slightly darker version of the original film from 10 years ago -- filled with unmotivated actions and wholly arbitrary plot twists. Add a slow-as-molasses first half, choppy editing, so-so effects and a chemistry-free love story, and you've hardly got a recipe for fun." And Rafer Guzmán in Long Island's Newsday calls the movie a "disappointment" and dismisses it as "a much-hyped, expensive-looking and ultimately soulless reboot." As for Garfield, Guzmán writes, he "makes for a sullen, sour Peter."



Tags: Spider Man - Andrew Garfield - Michael Phillips - Nevertheless - Saves The Day - Spider Man 3 - Tobey Maguire

Subscribe to Spider Man alerts

More Spider Man

Emma Stone Attends 'Birdman' Premiere At 71st Venice Film Festival [Pictures]

Emma Stone looked fabulous whilst attending the opening of the 71st Venice Film Festival on Wednesday (27th August). Emma Stone was sporting a new haircut...

Noisy 'Neighbors' Ready to Crash Spider-Man's Party with $35 Million Bow

The critical derision directed towards The Amazing Spider-Man 2 wasn't enough to stop Sony pulling in $95 million last week, though its long campaign to...

If Spider-Man Is So Amazing, Why Isn't He In 'The Avengers'?

Marvel Comics characters are all over cinema screens this year, from Captain America to Spider-Man to the forthcoming X-Men and Guardians of the Galaxy. But...

Spider-Man is Jewish. Because Andrew Garfield Says So.

He's The Amazing Spider-Man, and he's very much Jewish - this according to the man that plays the superhero in the latest franchise, Andrew Garfield....


'The Amazing Spiderman 2' To Weave Plot For 'Sinister Six' Spin-Off

The Amazing Spiderman 2 is set to be released on May 2nd in the US and April 18th in the UK, with the release date...

Batkid is Off to The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Premiere Following Oscars Disappointment

Miles Scott, also known as Batkid, is going to rub shoulders with the stars after all. The 5-year-old cancer survivor, who was made famous by...

Scorned By The Oscars, Batkid Visits Disneyland With Spiderman

Batkid may not have been around to save Leonardo di Caprio from another evening of Oscar disappointment but he's been enjoying himself with Spiderman at...

Christmas, Birthdays and 'Spider Man' - Sony Want Yearly Spidey Films

Not content with the upcoming Amazing Spider Man 2, starring Andrew Garfield, Emma Stone and expected to do big business at the box office, Sony...



Spider Man Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Spider Man

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All