Movie Reviews I Am Number Four

Subscribe to Roger Ebert alerts

Aliens versus teenagers battling it out on a high-school campus. The premise of I Am Number Four seems like it would make for a surefire hit at the box office. But it makes the Chicago Sun-Times' s movie critic, Roger Ebert, downright exasperated. It's sad, he writes, "when a movie casts aside all shame, demonstrates itself willing to rip off anything that might attract audiences, and Nevertheless fails." It all may be Shameless, but Gary Thompson in the Philadelphia Daily News suggests that director D.J. Caruso knows how to pack them in at the multiplex. He "makes movies that are cheerfully unoriginal and empty of calories, but propulsive, and Four is in that vein." Michael Phillips in the Chicago Tribune has the chutzpah to make the comment that many of his cohorts probably restrained themselves from making " I Am Number Four has more than a whiff of number two about it," he writes. Nevertheless, a few critics -- Brett Favre fans No Doubt -- don't spare their applause for Number Four. The Ending sets up the possibility of a sequel, and Roger Moore in the Orlando Sentinel says that it "makes this a franchise I won't mind seeing progress to a second movie." And Randy Cordova compares the movie with a good episode of the young Superman series Smallville "You may feel a bit silly watching it if you're past high-school age, but you just might have a good time."



Tags: Roger Ebert - Brett Favre - Michael Phillips - Nevertheless - No Doubt - Roger Moore - Shameless - Smallville - Superman - The Ending

Subscribe to Roger Ebert alerts

More Roger Ebert

Life Itself Movie Review

Fans of film journalism will love this documentary about the noted Chicago critic Roger Ebert, although the movie is just as much about his battle...

'The Maltese Falcon' Sells For $4 Million, But What's The Most Expensive Movie Item?

The Maltese Falcon, a statuette of a bird featuring in the classic 1941 detective thriller, sold for more than $4 million at Bonhams auction house...

Dance Tribute To Roger Ebert Led By Tilda Swinton, To Barry White Song

If there’s one thing Tilda Swinton knows how to do (and we reckon she knows how to do far more than just the one thing),...

Tilda Swinton Kicks Off Spontaneous Dance Party In Memory Of Roger Ebert

Tilda Swinton might be one of the most respected actresses in Hollywood, but the woman isn’t afraid to get down, yo! At the annual Ebertfest...


Ebertfest Day Two Continues To Celebrate The Legacy Of Roger Ebert

The passing of Roger Ebert earlier this month was met with unanimous respect for one of the movie industries' most revered critics and essayists. Over...

Late Film Critic Roger Ebert Laid To Rest At Chicago Cathedral

Roger Ebert funeral was held today in his native Illinois, with the great film critique laid to rest in front of family, friends and well...

Richard Roeper Remembers The Late Roger Ebert

Before his death on Thursday after a reoccurrence of cancer, Roger Ebert forged a reputation as a stellar film critic. His honest, brash style made...

Remembering Roger Ebert – The Late Critic Who Made Reviewing Films His Art

It’s not often actors and film directors combine to praise a film critic. But – such was his influence to cinema – it’s hard to...



Roger Ebert Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Roger Ebert

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All