Pink Floyd - Roger Waters' Regrets Over Pink Floyd's Cigar Song

Subscribe to Pink Floyd alerts

Pink Floyd star Roger Waters is still bitter he wasn't asked to sing the band's Wish You Were Here album fan favourite Have A Cigar - because he believes he would have done a better job than singer/songwriter Roy Harper.
Harper was recording at Abbey Road in London while the rock supergroup worked on the album in a nearby studio and when Waters and bandmate Dave Gilmour were struggling to find the right voice for the anti-music industry song, they agreed to let their folk singer pal give it a go.
Gilmour loved Harper's version and persuaded his bandmates to use it on their classic 1975 album - but 30-plus years later, Waters still thinks he would have done a better job with a little time.
In a candid new interview, which features on upcoming Dvd Pink Floyd: The Story of Wish You Were Here, Waters reveals, "He was singing a sort of parody... which I don't like. I never liked it... I regret it.
"I think if I'd persevered with it, I would have done it better... I think if I'd have sung it, it would have been more vulnerable and less cynical than the way he did it."
But former bandmate Gilmour disagrees, adding, "He (Harper) went off and did it and did a great job... (but) I don't think Roger liked his version very much."
And Harper himself has regrets about putting his voice on a Pink Floyd hit.
He explains, "It was played millions of times around the world... (and) it was a number-one selling single. Everyone thought it was Roger (singing). I was a bit peed off about that.
"The worst of it is sometimes when I'm doing a gig, some wag will shout, 'Have a cigar!'"


Tags: Pink Floyd - Roger Waters

Subscribe to Pink Floyd alerts

More Pink Floyd

Pink Floyd And David Bowie Help Boost UK Vinyl Sales Past The One Million Mark For The First Time In Nearly Two Decades

It seems that vinyl is once again back in fashion (thanks hipsters). This year, vinyl sales in the UK have passed the one million mark...

Good Way To Go - Pink Floyd's "Endless River" Tops UK Chart

And they’re back! By them, I obviously mean Pink Floyd and by back, I mean their new album , The Endless River, has topped the...

There's Hope For Us Yet! Pink Floyd Likely To Beat One Direction

It's frustrating for any musical connoisseur that carefully manipulated pop reigns highest on most music charts, but it looks like psychedelic legends Pink Floyd could...

Stephen Hawking To Feature On New Pink Floyd Album ‘The Endless River’

The voice of physicist Stephen Hawking will appear on Pink Floyd’s new album The Endless River, on a tracked titled, ‘Talkin' Hawkin.’Pink Floyd's Dave GilmourIt’s...


Pink Floyd Reveal Artwork For New Album ‘The Endless River’

The artwork for Pink Floyd’s long awaited new album, The Endless River was revealed this week at London’s South Bank with an eight metre lit...

Pink Floyd. "The Endless River." This November. It's Happening

Stop everything that you’re doing right now. Pink Floyd have a new album coming out in November. No, seriously. The rock icons are releasing their...

Roger Waters Concedes 'The Wall' is "Anti-War, Protest Movie"

Pink Floyd's Roger Waters says his new movie Roger Waters: The Wall should be viewed as a protest against the growing spread of armed conflict,...

Everything You Need To Know About Pink Floyd's New Album, 'The Endless River'

Fans of the psychedelic rock band Pink Floyd are in for a promising fall. Apparently the iconic rockers have a new album on the way...



Pink Floyd Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Pink Floyd

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All