Movie Reviews: The Smurfs 2

Subscribe Editors

Last time around The Smurfs got lousy reviews but managed to take in $563.7 million worldwide. This time around, The Smurfs 2 is getting even worse reviews but is still expected to win big at the box office, particularly overseas. It may, of course, be critic-proof. After all, what three-year-old reads reviews? But critics have a job to do and rarely can inform their editors that they'd like to opt out of reviewing a particular movie. Clearly none of them wants to come down too hard on the little blue characters. Neil Genzlinger in the New York Times simply remarks, The movie doesn't have the wit of the first installment and seems as if it might be hard for young children to follow, though who knows with young children? Mark Olsen in the Los Angeles Times concludes that it's no markedly better or worse than the first and with just enough difference to lay claim to being something new. And while Phil Brown in the Toronto Globe and Mail argues that the movie is deeply irritating for an adult, the does concede that the target audience should eat up this new round of Smurf shenanigans (Smurfanigans?) to the dismay of the parents who love their children enough to sit through the schmaltz. But Kyle Smith in the New York Post remarks that the film simply carries on with the legacy of inanity and the most positive thing he has to say about it is that occasionally there's a contemporary or grown-up reference to freshen up this moldy blue cheese. And Peter Hartlaub in the San Francisco Chronicle offers this advice: Save the $20 and just take your kid into the backyard to pull the wings off flies, or burn ants with a magnifying glass. There's so much torture and suffering in this movie, it starts to feel like Zero Dark Smurfy.


Tags: Editors - The New York Times - Phil Brown

Subscribe Editors

More Editors

Editors - Sugar Single Review

Editors released their fourth album 'The Weight Of Your Love' last year after a three year interval where they released nothing at all. During that...

A Week In Music, Justin Timberlake's 'Rude' Video, Dinosaur Pile-Up's Promising Second Album And Babyshambles Make A 'Sequel'

A week in music videos... It may have received bad press recently what with the video being banned from YouTube for its nude content and...

Editors - The Weight Of Your Love Album Review

Editors' fourth record has taken quite some time to emerge amid a period of change for the band. Yet it finds them revisiting largely familiar...

Editors - You Don't Know Love Video

You Don't Know Love video from EditorsEditors return with the new single 'You Don't Know Love' on January 25th 2010 taken from the hugely popular...


Editors - Push Your Head Towards The Air

Editors Push Your Head Towards The Air Single Review 'Tom Smith is God' proclaimed the pin badges when Editors first broke. Tongue in cheek perhaps,...

Editors, The Racing Rats Video Video

Editors The Racing Rats Video Editors release a new single from their Number One album, 'An End Has A Start' on November 26th 2007. 'The...

Editors, An End Has A Start Video Video

EditorsAn End Has A Start VideoEditors follow a Number One UK Album chart entry for their second album, `An End Has A Start' by releasing...

Editors - An End Has A Start

EditorsAn End Has A StartAlbum ReviewCommon wisdom suggests that it's always the third album of a band's career that's the difficult one. With Editors it's...



Editors Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Editors

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All